Sắc Bím Tài Khó All articles
Music

They Sampled the Song, Not the Story: Southeast Asian American Artists Are Done Letting Hollywood Take Without Asking

Sắc Bím Tài Khó
They Sampled the Song, Not the Story: Southeast Asian American Artists Are Done Letting Hollywood Take Without Asking

There's a particular kind of anger that comes from hearing something sacred in the wrong place. Maybe it's a Khmer court melody floating under a Hollywood action sequence. Maybe it's a Vietnamese folk tune chopped and pitched into a pop star's bridge. Maybe it's a Lao ceremonial chant that somehow ended up as ambient texture in a streaming series nobody asked Southeast Asians to consult on.

For a lot of Southeast Asian American musicians, that anger has been sitting in the chest for years. Now, a growing number of them are turning it into action.

The Borrowing That Doesn't Come Back

Let's be real about what's happening. Traditional Southeast Asian music — folk songs, ceremonial compositions, regional melodies passed down through generations — has long been treated by Western entertainment as a kind of open pantry. Production houses and mainstream artists pull from it freely, usually under the logic that it's "world music," "public domain," or simply too obscure for anyone to notice.

But people notice.

Kalyani Sisavath, a Lao American musician and ethnomusicologist based in Minneapolis, has been cataloging instances of unlicensed or uncredited use of Southeast Asian traditional music in American media for the past four years. Her running document — which she shares selectively with other researchers and advocates — has over 80 entries. Films, TV shows, video games, and commercial advertisements. Some entries involve direct sampling. Others involve what she calls "melodic extraction" — where a composer clearly studied a regional piece and reconstructed it just enough to avoid a paper trail.

"The intent is obvious when you know the source material," she says. "But because most Americans don't know the source material, it slides right through."

Who Owns a Lullaby?

The legal question is genuinely complicated, and that's part of what makes this fight so hard. Copyright law in the United States doesn't protect traditional folk music the same way it protects original compositions. If a melody has been sung communally for centuries, it's often classified as public domain — which means, technically, anyone can use it.

But "technically legal" and "ethically right" are not the same thing, and Southeast Asian American advocates are pushing hard on that distinction.

Thida Keo, a Cambodian American entertainment lawyer in Los Angeles, works with independent artists navigating exactly these issues. She's careful about what she can promise legally, but she's direct about the broader problem.

"The public domain argument gets used as a shield," she says. "These companies know the communities these songs come from. They know those communities are in the US. They just also know those communities historically haven't had the resources to challenge them."

That calculus is starting to shift.

The Documentation Game

One of the most effective tools the new generation of advocates has isn't a lawyer — it's a phone and a platform.

When a major streaming service dropped a docuseries last year that used what sounded unmistakably like a traditional Filipino kulintang arrangement as background music — with no composer credit, no cultural consultant listed, and no apparent licensing agreement — a Filipino American musician in San Jose posted a 90-second video breaking it down side by side. It got shared across multiple diaspora communities. The platform quietly updated the credits within two weeks.

That's not a legal victory. But it's something.

Nguyen Phuong Linh, a Vietnamese American producer and cultural commentator who goes by the name Linh Dao online, has been doing similar work for years. She's particularly focused on the Vietnamese music industry's tangled relationship with Hollywood, where traditional quan họ folk songs and cải lương compositions have appeared in everything from video game soundtracks to luxury brand campaigns.

"Social media is the only leverage most of us have," she says. "Labels and studios respond to public embarrassment faster than they respond to legal letters, especially when the story is easy to explain in a caption."

When the Credit Shows Up but the Check Doesn't

Sometimes the credit is there. That doesn't mean everything is fine.

Crediting a traditional song as "Traditional Vietnamese" or "Hmong folk melody" is better than nothing, but it doesn't put money in anyone's hands. It doesn't acknowledge the specific community, the regional tradition, or the living musicians who carry that music forward. And it certainly doesn't fund the cultural institutions — the music schools, the community centers, the youth programs — that are keeping these traditions alive in the US.

A growing number of Southeast Asian American artists are pushing for what some are calling "cultural royalty" frameworks: agreements where studios and labels that use traditional music contribute financially to diaspora cultural organizations, even when the music itself isn't technically owned by anyone.

It's an idea that hasn't gained mainstream legal traction yet, but it's picking up support in advocacy spaces, particularly among younger artists who grew up watching their parents' music get used and discarded.

"My mom sang those songs to me," says Mailee Xiong, a Hmong American singer-songwriter based in Sacramento. "My grandmother sang them to her. When I hear them in a trailer for something that has nothing to do with us, I don't feel flattered. I feel robbed."

Building the Infrastructure to Fight Back

What's different now compared to ten or fifteen years ago isn't just the anger — it's the organization.

Small but serious networks of Southeast Asian American musicians, lawyers, academics, and cultural workers are connecting across cities, sharing documentation, pooling resources, and building the kind of institutional knowledge that makes sustained advocacy possible. Groups operating out of cities like Seattle, Houston, Long Beach, and the Twin Cities are hosting workshops on music copyright, traditional knowledge protections, and how to engage entertainment industry gatekeepers.

Some are also going directly to music schools and film programs, pushing for curriculum that teaches students — future composers, music supervisors, and directors — about the ethical dimensions of borrowing from living cultural traditions.

"We're not trying to make it impossible to be inspired by Southeast Asian music," says Thida Keo. "We're trying to make it so that inspiration comes with responsibility. That's not a radical ask."

The Song Remembers Who Sang It First

There's something worth sitting with here. These aren't abstract compositions that appeared out of nowhere. They are songs with histories — songs that marked harvests, mourned the dead, welcomed children into the world, survived displacement and war and resettlement. They came to the United States in the memories of refugees and immigrants who had already lost so much.

Using them without acknowledgment isn't just a legal gray area. It's a continuation of the same erasure that Southeast Asian communities have been navigating for decades.

The artists fighting back know they're not going to win every case. The legal system isn't built for this fight, and the entertainment industry's appetite for "exotic" sound isn't going away. But they're building something that matters regardless: a record, a community, and a set of expectations that didn't exist before.

Next time a melody from the Mekong shows up in a Marvel trailer, somebody's going to be ready to say something. And more people than ever are going to be listening.

All Articles

Related Articles

Something Old, Something 808: Inside the World of Southeast Asian American Wedding DJs

Something Old, Something 808: Inside the World of Southeast Asian American Wedding DJs

Making Hits From the Midwest: How Southeast Asian American Bedroom Producers Are Breaking Through Without the Big City

Making Hits From the Midwest: How Southeast Asian American Bedroom Producers Are Breaking Through Without the Big City

The Spirit Doesn't Need a Subtitle: Southeast Asian American Horror Creators Are Making the Supernatural Their Own

The Spirit Doesn't Need a Subtitle: Southeast Asian American Horror Creators Are Making the Supernatural Their Own